did his body of work stack up to any of them? I'll be the asshole and say NO.
punk rock and "youth culture" does not make powerful art. sorry...
...and then i hear of the passing of dorothea tanning. at 101...
tanning was (or is) one of the female artists nobody knows but should know. a lot of her work comes off a bit spotty to my eyes-- and much comes off as horribly dated. but she was there, working her paint, digging down deep into her own reality. and yes, as a woman, who knows the peripheral bullshit she had to deal with?
the surrealists were a dicey lot. effete, cafe society europeans- laying low in nyc while the nazis did what they did.
breton? please... a bad poet does not a leader make.
but, as a whole, the surrealists took us all to another place-- looking at and making art.
tanning, in her very existence as a woman putting down paint and living the life she led is a beacon for BEING AN ARTIST and LEADING A full CREATIVE LIFE...
all that and she nailed down a multi-decade marriage to an artist.
god knows that can't be easy.
kelley? well, yeah...
at least we still have hirst.